Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> Atrophy. I've already noticed that I am slowly starting to atrophy my ability to write code manually... > Largely due to all the little mostly syntactic details involved in programming, you can review code just fine even if you struggle to write it.

Until you struggle to review it as well. Simple exercise to prove it - ask LLM to write a function in familiar programming language, but in the area you didn't invest learning and coding yourself. Try reviewing some code involving embedding/SIMD/FPGA without learning it first.





People would struggle to review code in a completely unfamiliar domain or part of the stack even before LLMs.

That’s why you need to write code to learn it.

No-one has ever learned skill just by reading/observing


"No-one has ever learned skill just by reading/observing" - Except of course all of those people in Cosmology who, you know, observe.

what skill do they have? making stars? no they are skilled at observing, which is what they do.

I think understanding stellar processes and then using that understanding to theorize about other observations is a skill. My point was that observing can be a fantastic way to build a skill.. not all skills, but certainly some skills. Learning itself is as much an observation as a practice.

How would you find yourself in that situation before AI?

No, because they wouldn't be so foolish as to try it.



Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: