Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Right but if you want a favorable trade deal then you gotta throw in some immigration sweeteners.




Particularly with India, that's normally one of their top requests.

Why is it a top request from India? What does the Indian government get out of letting their kids overpay for education abroad?

1. ~4% of their GDP is from remittances, compared to <1% a few decades ago[0]

2. India has a massive male surplus[1] and they actively look to send them abroad to prevent domestic unrest

[0] https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/BX.TRF.PWKR.DT.GD.ZS?lo...

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demographics_of_India


> look to send them abroad to prevent domestic unrest

Great, now other countries can import and share that domestic social unrest from the oversupply of frustrated reproductive age celibate males, all in the name of making GDP number go up. Lovely.

Surely using hindsight of documented history and well researched human behavior science, we can't already predict this will lead to a rise in political far right extremism, and everyone will be shocked as if it will suddenly come out of nowhere, and then the local males will exclusively be to blame for it, leading to further frustration, radicalisation and disenfranchisement. Surely this is not EXACTLY what's gonna happen.


India gets a metric fuckload of money back in remittances every year. Debatable if that's actually worth the brain drain, but then there's also the angle of having your young people learn from the rest of the world and return with new skills. I lean more towards the remittances though.

Governments don’t want smart people. They want dumb people because they are easier to control.

Are dumb people, in fact, easier to control?

I have seen a lot of smart people in thrall of ideologies that could be used to manipulate them left and right at will. Meanwhile, true morons tend to be unpredictably chaotic.


Yea. Dumb people are lower class and uneducated. Give them a few bonuses and they’ll happily shut up.

This explains why governments never subsidize universities

Most do enough to keep their people from revolting.

They can then reserve even more seats in education for the "oppressed."

Mark Carney should know that it would be an _extremely_ unpopular move right now to allow India more access to immigrate here.

"Should know" and expecting a logical outcome is wishful.



Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: