Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

What do you mean, “once we start”? It has always been. The only really unusual thing about this instance is that the target was not the sort of person who’s traditionally been seen as deserving it.


Things have notably gotten worse over the last decade or so, if that hasn’t been made abundantly clear.


Perhaps, but on a longer time horizon none of this is new.


On a longer time horizon the norm is brutal warfare that leaves many innocent people dead.

I don’t think we should be so keen to embrace that.


Even in times of peace, Americans love our righteous killings and murderous folk heroes.

I’m not keen to embrace it. But I think the finger-wagging is idiotic. Chastising people will accomplish nothing except for making them think you’re out of touch.

Folks disturbed by this outpouring of support for this murder should instead be asking why people feel that way. Maybe it’s because of a system that treats their lives as an expense to be minimized and gives them no recourse. If wide support for Luigi Mangione worries you, maybe look at fixing that.


Seems like you’re awfully annoyed by this conversation so I’ll let it go, but I hope you remember this convo the next time this happens to someone.

Right now, Daniel Penny is being celebrated by half the country for killing Neely, and the other half wishes something like this would happen to him.


I keep getting this response and I do not understand it. Why would I change my opinion just because other people might disagree?

It’s especially bizarre here because I haven’t even expressed an opinion about the killing. All I said is that love of killers is nothing new, and if you want it to stop then you need to change the circumstances that make people like killing, rather than just telling them that they’re bad.


There is a belief that Daniel Penny acted in the direct defense of those in the area. That is quite different than killing a CEO who is probably going to be replaced by the same type of person.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: