Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin
New EU push for chat control: Will messenger services be blocked in Europe? (patrick-breyer.de)
21 points by doener on Sept 13, 2024 | hide | past | favorite | 4 comments


As of now, there are no solid plans to block messaging services in Europe. The proposal in the EU's Act on Content Moderation suggested the potential chance for blocking messaging services.

Hosting on own messaging server or relying on the global matrix servers is still grounds for debate.


It shouldn't be on Signal and co to stop operating in the EU, it should be on its citizens to stop operating the EU.

Most legislation of its members comes from the EU in a rather undemocratic process. I have lost faith in the idea for it not to become bureaucratic madness. The bad does outweigh the benefits.


What happens if I run my own messaging server?

What happens from dumb cases like an IRC server to more "complex" cases like running my own "matrix" servers?

On a more serious note: Nicola Gratteri, an italian magistrate known to be the most wanted (dead) by the mafia in italy, has said in many occasions that the mafia has strong enough funding (duh) and competencies to "build their own whatsapp", as in building its own telecommunication network for covert communications outside of mainstream/public services.

youtube short, excerpt from an interview (in italian, though): https://www.youtube.com/shorts/JkPeyFrSJrk

So who's gonna benefit from chat control? Most likely authoritarian states that have one more tool to prosecute citizens and dissidents.


Funny how the article gets the small providers like signal as example as if Messenger, WhatsApp, telegram shouldnt be responsible for all the crimes they profit from




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: