Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> The tax-man and the police state are the oppressors

The oppressors _of whom_? For example taxing billionaires is not "oppression". I completely agree that modern tax policy is much too burdensome on relatively poor individuals in comparison to relatively wealthy ones (certainly given the amount of money spent on policing petty crime compared to catching large-scale tax evasion), but that isn't to say we shouldn't have taxes!



> The oppressors _of whom_?

The taxed and the prosecuted.

Taxes aren’t an inherent ethical imperative, and certainly not something for which we should accept endless government intrusion in service of the collection thereof.

Taxes are an imperfect mechanism for funding an imperfect state, not an innate moral right to spend the fruits of others’ labor.


> The taxed and the prosecuted.

You said this before but which taxed people and which prosecuted are you thinking of?

> Taxes aren’t an inherent ethical imperative

Even if this is not true, there are certainly a number of pragmatic reasons to support them (it turns out it's much nicer to live somewhere where there is a fair and just judicial system, a functioning education system, roads/bridges/etc, internet, clean water, sewage systems and social protection for the less fortunate and well off).




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: