Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> No, it does not. A number of Eastern Europe countries are in NATO and none of them have American nuclear weapons.

Yet. There were murmurs about moving them from Germany to Eastern Europe.

Additionally - US has DCAs (Defense Cooperation Agreement; straightly bilateral, nothing to do with NATO) with most EE countries. Nobody knows, what they brought there, US is certainly not telling anyone. The nukes might be already there.



There are no ICBMS in Germany only tactical bombs... these have no military value, there only value is to say that European countries have shared nuclear deterrence.

And Russia is big, they have an immense second strike capability from land and from the sea. Wladiwostok is 8000km away from Kiev.


I agree with your sentiment, but to say that a weapon capable of creating a Coloseum-sized crater has "no military value" seems a bit off.

On the other hand i cannot think of a critical role played by ICBM's in Central Europe, could your share some insights?


It has no military value because it's unthinkable to use them. Unlike strategic weapons of deterrence which are exactly meant to prevent unthinkable scenarios. We have them so the other side won't use theirs.

Tactical weapons are not deterrence but actually meant to be used. Nobody will use a tactical nuke for the can of worms it represents. Whatever target can be found for a tactical weapon, it's not important enough to justify a nuke and basically start WW3.. They're a leftover of 50/60s doctrine.


Strictly speaking, US doesn't need ICBMs in Europe, would be ineffective there... just enough weaponry to prevent Russia to use theirs for retaliation.


I wonder why they are considering moving those? Hmm? You should be ashamed of parroting Russian propaganda at this time.


It is just you, who uses aggressive, emotive rhetoric in multiple comments in this thread ("parroting Russian propaganda").

Please engage based on arguments, and do not do personal attacks even if you don't like them.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: