Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Shock doctrine had some great points like about the economic collapse of Russia and South Africa in the early 90's under neoliberalism.


I can think of a couple of issues which might underlie the economic issues of South Africa and Russia: namely thee end of one party rule in both states.

There really was no 'collapse' of the South African economy - it's been growing rapidly since the end of apartheid. Just some chaos during the transition. Crime expanded quite a lot and it had nothing to do with 'neoliberalism'.

And both nations would have had to go a heavy and chaotic transitionary period.

To imply that it was part of some cabal of Western Imperialist 'Doctrine' is completely false.

There were a lot of resources up for grabs - and a lot of money ploughing in.

Naomi Klein is part of the reason I dropped supporting SJW/leftist causes by default, I'm pretty skeptical these days, I pick and chose.


There was a dramatic downturn in the South African economy after 1994, not a collapse like Russia but our industry took a huge knock, the Rand weaken dramatically, there was vast disinvestment and job losses. Yes there was growth, but like all neoliberal regimes it has gone to the wealthiest 1%. Today South Africa is significantly worse in most social indicators than it was in 1994.


"Today South Africa is significantly worse in most social indicators than it was in 1994."

And do you blame this on capitalists? Or do you blame this on your utterly, completely and totally corrupt and inefficient political system?

Which one do you think is the source of the problem? :)

Because we have capitalism here in Canada and are doing just fine.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: